Monday, December 21, 2009

I've Created A (Cookie) Monster!!

Last year, I was invited to participate in a cookie exchange at the home of one of Oldest Boy's classmates. It was a very nice little party - more like an "open house" really - and the food was delish. Oldest Boy enjoyed playing with the other kids from his class and I enjoyed getting to know some of the parents.

However, the cookie "exchange" part...left something to be desired. I made my cake balls - which are one of my favorite cookies and usually a big hit. The hostess later asked me for the recipe during lent so she could make a non-chocolate treat (they can be made using any flavor combination). The cookies that I was sent home with were, uh, well, er...AWFUL!! I think the idea is that you bake a boatload of one type of cookie and you end up with one dozen of a bunch of different types. {SIGH} I hadn't really counted on it last year to substitute for my holiday baking so at least I wasn't too disappointed.

At least this year I knew what I was getting into. I attended again and made the same cookies. Again, I came home with, um, yuck. I knew I was in trouble from the start. We had rehearsed the whole way there what proper behavior was if we didn't like something we were offered or that we decided to try. Youngest Boy (who will likely attend Kindergarten with one of their children) sampled a chocolate chip cookie (which he loves when I bake them). He took a nibble, turned to me, and said, "No thank you." I figured I would just finish it up for him (it's the holidays). The "baker" was standing next to me so I had to choke it down but holy guacamole it was maybe the worst chocolate chip cookie I've ever had! {SIGH}

Now, maybe I'm a better baker than I give myself credit for. Or maybe I'm just picky. But seriously. I thought the idea was to make something you would be proud of. Let's just say my trained super-taster husband threw away more than half of the cookies I brought home. And I've been baking my hiney off ever since!!

Fa-la-la-la-la...la-la-la-la!!

**I'd like to give credit to two of the "bakers". The hostess distributed a poor substitute for buckeye cookies BUT her lady locks were almost as good as my SIL's (Donna) - this is maybe the highest compliment I can give lady locks. Another woman made fudge...which is currently hidden in the back of my fridge. I'll be darned if I'm giving away the only edible treat I took home for all of my hard work!

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

My sister is forever saying, "I can't cook - I guess I just didn't get the cooking gene." It drives me batty! How hard is it to follow a recipe?! I was complaining about this to my husband last week, about an hour before my neighbor brought over some cookies that she and her girls had made. AWFUL. I could have re-shingled my roof with some of them. I stand corrected: cooking/baking takes some talent. And your story is exactly why I am thankful I have never been invited to a cookies exchange!

Rocket Ma'am said...

I've never understood how you can have so many different batches of toll-house cc cookies when the recipe on the chip bag has been the same for decades!
Try these: http://therocketscientistsguidetoraisingkids.blogspot.com/2008/12/guns-and-glucose.html

Can't eat less than a dozen per sitting...